We all make requests every day—asking our friends to join us for lunch, asking classmates to borrow notes, asking our roommates not to leave their dirty socks on the floor. In these everyday encounters, it’s easy to tell if people are agreeing readily, agreeing reluctantly, or refusing. “We navigate and negotiate consent in interactions in our environment all the time—it’s intrinsic to social success and functioning,” says Cari Ionson, Sexual Violence Response and Awareness Coordinator at Mount Royal University in Alberta. “We’re constantly reading and monitoring people’s verbal and nonverbal cues to see if there’s agreement, invitation, acceptance, etc., or not.”
Does this sound painfully obvious? Good, because it is. The ability to read people’s signals of agreement and refusal is a skill set we develop very early in life. When we ask people to do things, most of us are very good at reading their response and determining whether they are agreeing or refusing. If the signals are mixed or confusing—that is, if the response is ambiguous—it’s easy to spot that as well. “Interpreting cues can take a bit more effort when people are impaired (for example, by exhaustion, intoxication, or anxiety),” says Dr. Melanie Boyd, who runs programming designed to create a more positive sexual and romantic culture at Yale University in the US. “But those deeply ingrained skills don’t desert us even then.”
- Brief, direct answers, such as “Sure!”
- Concrete planning (e.g., “I’d love to! When?”)
- Direct eye contact
- A step toward you
- Nodding and smiling
- Long, indirect answers with pauses, such as “Oh, I’d love to…but I actually have to finish a paper…”
- Avoiding eye contact
- Looking closed off
- Leaning away
Consent: Critical, but not complicated
Sometimes, people act as if consent around sex is totally different from consenting to nonsexual things in life, as if we need some special training to interpret signals of agreement and refusal in romantic or sexual contexts. This simply isn’t true. Research shows we use the same everyday signals—both verbal and nonverbal—to communicate interest in sexual situations as we do in everyday life. For example, study participants reported easily being able to understand their partner’s subtle, nonverbal forms of agreement and refusal during typical sexual encounters, according to a 2010 study of 21 young adults published in Culture, Health, and Sexuality.
“If I were to ask someone to go to the movies with me, and they didn’t want to, they probably wouldn’t give an explicit ‘no.’ What’s more likely is they would say, ‘I already have plans’ or ‘I can’t tonight,’” says Ionson. “We see this play out in sexual situations as well. Look for both the yes and the no through words and body language, and if it isn’t clear, ask.”
Some people have genuine difficulty interpreting nonverbal language and social cues. This has implications for establishing mutual sexual consent.
What to say to your partner if understanding body language is hard for you
“I don’t always pick up on body language, so if I misunderstand you, it’s not intentional. Please tell me directly what you want and what you don’t want.”
What to say to your partner if understanding body language is hard for them
“Let’s be direct so we’re sure to understand each other. I’ll tell you what I want and what I don’t want. What do you want?”
How misunderstandings can happen
“This is mainly about the ability to read other people’s intentions and thoughts,” says Dr. Isabelle Hénault, a sexologist and psychologist based in Montreal, Quebec. “Especially with individuals with Asperger syndrome or other autism conditions, they rarely act out with a negative intention. Any problems are most likely about misreading situations.”
So what exactly is consent?
Consent is a clear, voluntary, and ongoing agreement to engage in a sexual encounter. Spotting agreement is obvious, and anything less is not consent.
This doesn’t make us mind readers; we can’t know someone’s innermost desires or what they will want in the future. But we can tell if someone is actively engaged in an encounter or if they are anything less than engaged.
Raising the bar above consent
Consent is necessary. If you choose to engage in sexual or romantic encounters, it’s critical to pay attention to and respect your partner’s signals of agreement, and you should expect your partner to do the same.
However, we—as individuals and as communities—want encounters that are more than just consensual. “The ideal is a genuinely mutual, engaged, connected encounter that’s working for both people,” says Dr. Boyd. This means holding out for encounters that are not just consensual but also enthusiastic. We aren’t just looking for the “yes” of consent—we’re looking for the “YES!” of enthusiasm. “Consent with enthusiasm encourages healthier and connected experiences and relationships,” Ionson says.
Why enthusiasm is the goal
Enthusiastic encounters are better for our community, and they’re a lot more pleasurable. “By making absolutely sure that your partner wants to be involved in what you’re doing sexually, you’re…going to have a [better] time. You’ll know what they want, in their own words. You can gauge from the way their eyelids flutter (or close), the way their breathing gets heavier, the way their body squirms as they answer your questions. And being on the receiving end of those questions (even if it makes you blush!) is pretty sexy,” writes Rachel Kramer Bussel, a journalist and blogger, in the anthology Yes Means Yes: Visions of Female Sexual Power and a World Without Rape (Seal Press, 2008).
Enthusiasm in a sexual or romantic encounter looks a lot like enthusiasm in everyday contexts. “I’ve always found it really clear if both parties are engaged and interested,” says Katie R.*, a third-year undergraduate at the University of Victoria in British Columbia in a recent Student Health 101 survey. “You both smile, there’s electricity, it’s exciting. [There’s a] super-stark difference when someone is not interested. They won’t make eye contact, their shoulders are clenched, very tense, they’re quiet.”
How can you make sure that your encounters are as enthusiastic as you’d like them to be? “Furthering the conversation in a positive way is fun,” Twanna A. Hines, the sex writer behind the Funky Brown Chick blog and Twitter account, told Student Health 101. Try questions like these, she says: “What are you into? What’s the hottest thing you’ve ever tried?”
Here are some in-the-moment strategies from our student readers
Students recommend saying...
“Tell me something that excites you.”
—Sophia T.*, first-year graduate student, University of New Brunswick
“I feel better when I’m touched here. Can you try that?”
—Peyton G.*, fourth-year undergraduate, Memorial University of Newfoundland, Newfoundland and Labrador
“I’d love it if you did this to me. Do you want to do that to me/can you do that for me?”
—James P.*, first-year graduate student, Queen’s University, Ontario
Students recommend saying...
“Something seems a little off tonight. Should we save this for another time?”
—Sydney M.*, third-year graduate student, University of Victoria, British Columbia
“I stopped what we were doing and asked what was wrong. She admitted something was bugging her, so we stopped and had a long discussion about what was going on.”
—Matt B.*, second-year undergraduate, St. Clair College, Ontario
“When I notice my partner isn’t as enthusiastic as I would expect, I’d ask, ‘What are your hesitations?’, ‘Are you OK with this?’, or ‘Can I do something to help you relax?’”
—Sam R.*, third-year undergraduate, Southern Alberta Institute of Technology
Students recommend saying...
“I’ve got work tomorrow, right now isn’t the best time.”
—Amanda W.*, fourth-year undergraduate, Memorial University, Newfoundland and Labrador
“Try not to use the term ‘tonight.’ If you’re really not interested in someone, you may not want them to think that it’s just the circumstances of that night or day that makes you not desire sexual interaction with them; using an absolute ‘no’ can be best in those cases.”
—Angie M.*, fifth-year student, Queen’s University, Ontario
“A simple ‘no.’ This makes it clear and helps set boundaries. This will also be clear to your partner that you’re not going to be persuaded and simply don’t want to engage.”
—Jamie V.*, third-year undergraduate, Southern Alberta Institute of Technology
Handling unwanted pressure
If you ever do encounter sexual pressure, you can look around for intervention and support. In the moment, seek out authority figures such as party hosts or bouncers who can help you if you need it. If you’re looking for an excuse to leave an uncomfortable situation, try texting a friend and asking them to call you, or simply get up and leave. If you do experience pressured sex—if someone pushes your boundaries or crosses them—you may find that talking about it is helpful. Reach out to friends, family members, and university resources such as a dean, a chaplain, the counselling centre, or the health centre, or check out the Canadian Association of Sexual Assault Centres for helpful resources and phone numbers for sexual assault centres across the country.
The mindset: Holding out for ideal sexual encounters
Reflect on what you want from intimacy, romance, and sex. When we do this, we all benefit. For example, our sexual encounters will be more engaged and pleasurable; we can feel confident that our decisions to have sex or not will be respected; and we can all feel more comfortable checking in with our partners to find the practices that work best for us. Working together, we can build campuses where enthusiastic encounters are the norm.
*Student names have been changed for privacy
Melanie Boyd, PhD, Assistant Dean in Student Affairs; Lecturer in Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies, Yale University, Connecticut.
Isabelle Hénault, PhD, Director, Clinique Autisme et Asperger de Montréal, Quebec.
Twanna A. Hines, sexuality writer at http://funkybrownchick.com/.
Cari Ionson, MSW, RSW, Sexual Violence Response and Awareness Coordinator, Mount Royal University, Alberta.
Beres, M. (2010). Sexual miscommunication? Untangling assumptions about sexual communication between casual sex partners. Culture, Health & Sexuality, 12(1), 1–14.
Beres, M. A. (2014). Rethinking the concept of consent for anti-sexual violence activism and education. Feminism & Psychology, 24(3), 373–389.
Beres, M. A., Senn, C. Y., & McCaw, J. (2014). Navigating ambivalence: How heterosexual young adults make sense of desire differences. Journal of Sex Research, 51(7), 765–776.
Boyd, M. (2014, December 17). The case for affirmative consent [Blog post]. Huffington Post. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/melanie-boyd/the-case-for-affirmative-consent_b_6312476.html
Carmody, M. (2003). Sexual ethics and violence prevention. Social & Legal Studies, 12(2), 199–216. Retrieved from http://doi.org/10.1177/0964663903012002003
Friedman, J. (2011). What you really really want: The smart girl’s shame-free guide to sex and safety. Berkeley, CA: Seal Press.
Friedman, J., & Valenti, J. (2008). Yes means yes: Visions of female sexual power and a world without rape. Berkeley, CA: Seal Press.
Grasgreen, A. (2013, June 5). Yale program to shift sexual assault culture goes beyond rape prevention. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2013/06/05/yale-program-shift-sexual-assault-culture-goes-beyond-rape-prevention
Halley, J. (2016). The move to affirmative consent. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 42(1), 257–279.
Kimmel, M., & Steinem, G. (2014, September 4). Michael Kimmel and Gloria Steinem on consensual sex on campus. New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/05/opinion/michael-kimmel-and-gloria-steinem-on-consensual-sex-on-campus.html
Kitzinger, C., & Frith, H. (1999). Just say no? The use of conversation analysis in developing a feminist perspective on sexual refusal. Discourse & Society, 10(3), 293–316.
Kramer Bussel, R. (2008). Beyond yes or no: Consent as sexual process. In J. Friedman & J. Valenti (Eds.), Yes means yes: Visions of female sexual power and a world without rape (43–52). Berkeley, CA: Seal Press.
McDonough, K. (2014, September 5). Gloria Steinem on consent and sexual assault: “Since when is hearing ‘yes’ a turnoff?” Salon. Retrieved from http://www.salon.com/2014/09/05/gloria_steinem_on_consent_and_sexual_assault_since_when_is_hearing_yes_a_turnoff/
O’Byrne, R., Hansen, S., & Rapley, M. (2007). If a girl doesn’t say “no…”: Young men, rape, and claims of insufficient knowledge. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 18(3), 168–193.
Steele, C. M., & Josephs, R. A. (1990). Alcohol myopia: Its prized and dangerous effects. American Psychologist, 45(8), 921.
Walker-Wells, E. (2016, October 1). Get empowered: Finding yourself in dating and in life. Student Health 101 High School. Retrieved from http://demonstration.getsh101.com/finding-yourself-in-dating-and-life/
Walker-Wells, E. (2016, April 1). Let’s talk about sex: How to share what you both want. Student Health 101. Retrieved from http://default.readsh101.com/talk-about-sex/
Yale CCEs. (n.d.). “Myth of miscommunication” workshops. Yale University. Retrieved from http://cce.yalecollege.yale.edu/myth-miscommunication-workshops